Other1 min read

Miffed lawyer questions CJI's 'integrity', advocates seek action against him

By · Via Times of India · Published by Everything Blog

In short

An unscheduled mentioning over a petition filed on November 2 quickly escalated when a lawyer challenged Chief Justice Surya Kant's integrity inside the courtroom. A registry official explained that an automated system handles petition listings, which had fallen behind due to a week-long Diwali court closure. Rather than approaching the registrar for an early listing as directed, the lawyer refused the bench's offer to examine the issue. Disturbed by the disruption, several members of the bar met with the CJI to demand contempt proceedings against the advocate.

Key points

  • Court protocol requires advocates to contact the registrar directly when seeking an early…: Court protocol requires advocates to contact the registrar directly when seeking an early listing of a petition.
  • The lawyer openly challenged the Chief Justice of India's integrity and legitimacy to hol…: The lawyer openly challenged the Chief Justice of India's integrity and legitimacy to hold office despite an offer to review the issue.
  • Bar members have formally urged the Chief Justice of India to initiate contempt proceedin…: Bar members have formally urged the Chief Justice of India to initiate contempt proceedings over the lawyer's courtroom conduct.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

Some bar members requested the CJI to take action against the lawyer (File photo/PTI)

NEW DELHI: An alleged procedural lapse in non-listing of a petition filed on Nov 2 in Supreme Court evoked a disproportionate reaction from a lawyer who, while resorting to an unscheduled mentioning, created a scene and questioned Justice Surya Kant's legitimacy to continue as CJI.When the bench was in the midst of adjudicating some motor accident claim cases, a lawyer said the petition filed on Nov 2 was not yet listed despite intimation being given to the CJI's office.The court objected to the unscheduled mentioning and asked the lawyer to intimate the registrar for inclusion of his request for early listing. But the lawyer said he had already apologised and that he would like to know why the petition had not been listed.

When the CJI said he would look into it, the lawyer flared up and said, "No, I will not wait. You cannot sit in that chair. You do not deserve. You do not have the integrity for that."Listing of petitions is done by…

Other