Other1 min read

Michigan woman owed $1m by late ex-husband can pursue suit against deal's lawyer

By · Via Times of India · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The revived malpractice lawsuit stems from a divorce agreement that required Kevin Baker to pay Jamie Lee Baker $13,000 monthly across 111 months, secured by interests in multiple limited liability companies. Kevin died after making only 27 payments, leaving 84 installments unpaid and exposing major structural flaws in the pledged collateral. Probate proceedings revealed Kevin lacked direct personal ownership in five of the six promised entities because they were held under a parent company, LIP Holdings. Ultimately, buyout restrictions in the parent company's operating agreement reduced Baker's total recovery to less than half of the remaining debt.

Key points

  • The Michigan Court of Appeals reinstated Jamie Lee Baker's malpractice lawsuit against he…: The Michigan Court of Appeals reinstated Jamie Lee Baker's malpractice lawsuit against her former divorce attorney, Michael A. Robbins.
  • Attorney Michael A. Robbins allegedly failed to properly verify ownership of pledged coll…: Attorney Michael A. Robbins allegedly failed to properly verify ownership of pledged collateral and omitted a key trust from initial negotiations.
  • Unresolved factual questions regarding the adequacy of the divorce settlement's security…: Unresolved factual questions regarding the adequacy of the divorce settlement's security will now return to the lower court for further proceedings.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

Jamie Lee Baker’s divorce settlement promised her $13,000 a month for 111 months, secured by assignments of her former husband’s interests in several limited liability companies. When Kevin Baker died after making only 27 payments, 84 payments worth more than $1 million remained outstanding, and Jamie discovered that much of the collateral behind the agreement may not have been what she thought it was. On November 13, the Michigan Court of Appeals reversed a lower court’s dismissal of her legal malpractice lawsuit against attorney Michael A. Robbins, according to the Justia U.S Law case record.

The ruling does not decide whether Robbins was negligent. It does, however, send the case back for further proceedings after finding that there were genuine issues of material fact about whether the assignments in the divorce settlement actually provided the security Jamie was promised.

What the settlement promised

Jamie and Kevin Baker’s divorce settlement included property settlement payments of $13,000 per month for 111 months. To protect her if Kevin stopped paying, the agreement called for assignments of his membership interests in several LLCs, including…

Other