Finance1 min read

Man sells house, skips ITR & then claims capital gains exemption; what ITAT said

By · Via Times of India · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The case arose from the 2017-18 assessment year after an individual received a March 2024 reassessment notice following an unfiled return and a property purchase. The assessing officer and first appellate authority initially rejected the taxpayer's Rs 49 lakh Section 54 claim and added Rs 31,38,256 to his income. Overturning those decisions, the tribunal clarified that Section 54 does not mandate filing an original return by the prescribed due date to qualify for relief. The tribunal also noted that authorities had already accepted an identical claim from the taxpayer's wife for her 50 percent share of the property.

Key points

  • Section 54 tax exemptions cannot be rejected solely because a taxpayer failed to submit a…: Section 54 tax exemptions cannot be rejected solely because a taxpayer failed to submit an original income tax return.
  • Taxpayers undergoing reassessment can introduce statutory deductions that directly relate…: Taxpayers undergoing reassessment can introduce statutory deductions that directly relate to the specific escaped income under review.
  • The tribunal remanded the dispute back to the assessing officer to properly evaluate the…: The tribunal remanded the dispute back to the assessing officer to properly evaluate the merits of the exemption claim.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

Can you claim an exemption in your income tax return if you have not filed it originally and only initiate ITR filing after getting a notice from the

Income Tax Department?

In a relief for taxpayers, the Mumbai bench of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) has ruled that an exemption claim under Section 54 of the Income Tax (I-T) Act for reinvestment of capital gains in a new house cannot be rejected merely because the taxpayer did not initially file an income tax return.

The tribunal held that such a claim can be considered and allowed when it is made during reassessment proceedings.

What the case is about

The case concerned an individual taxpayer who had not submitted an original income tax return under Section 139(1).

The dispute concerned the assessment year 2017-18. According to the tribunal's order, the Income Tax Department had information that the man purchased an immovable property valued at Rs 45 lakh during the relevant year. Since he had not filed his income tax return, proceedings were initiated under Section 147 of the Income Tax…

Finance