Finance1 min read

Man buys flat with wife, faces Rs 14.25L addition for on-money claim; what ITAT said

By · Via Times of India · Published by Everything Blog

In short

Tax authorities reopened the individual's 2012-13 assessment, alleging he and his wife paid Rs 28.5 lakh in unrecorded cash for a Thane flat. The assessing officer relied on seized emails, an Excel sheet, and statements from the builder's executives to assign a Rs 14.25 lakh addition to the husband. However, lower authorities ignored the builder's written confirmation verifying receipt of the official Rs 72 lakh registered agreement value. The ITAT dismissed the addition because the department withheld the underlying digital records and denied the taxpayer the right to cross-examine key witnesses.

Key points

  • The ITAT ruled that third-party statements cannot serve as standalone evidence without of…: The ITAT ruled that third-party statements cannot serve as standalone evidence without offering the taxpayer an opportunity for cross-examination.
  • Tax assessments based on alleged cash transactions require authorities to establish a dir…: Tax assessments based on alleged cash transactions require authorities to establish a direct link to the buyer rather than relying on uncorroborated records.
  • Prior tribunal rulings had already dismissed similar uncorroborated additions issued agai…: Prior tribunal rulings had already dismissed similar uncorroborated additions issued against other property buyers from the same real estate developer.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

When you buy a property, it is very important to keep all records of transactions and payments. In case of an Income Tax Department query, documents form an important part of your defence.

The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Mumbai, has deleted a Rs 14.25 lakh addition made against a Thane flat buyer after the Income Tax Department alleged that he had paid money over and above the consideration recorded in the property agreement.

The tribunal observed that the Income Tax Department had failed to establish any link between the buyer and the alleged ‘on-money’ transaction. Read on to know what happened.

What the case is about

The dispute involved a man who purchased a flat in Thane, jointly with his wife for Rs 72 lakh. The property was registered in April 2012.

The man filed his income tax return for assessment year 2012-13, declaring income of Rs 2,71,280. The return was initially accepted, but the assessment was subsequently reopened after the department received information concerning alleged cash payments to the real estate developer from whom the flat had been…

Finance