Politics1 min read

Mahmoud Khalil sues Justice Department over failure to disclose correspondence with immigration judge

By · Via Middle East Eye · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The action follows an unfulfilled Freedom of Information Act request prompted by reporting that revealed expedited hearings and recusals among Board of Immigration Appeals members. Plainclothes agents originally revoked Mahmoud Khalil's student visa and Green Card, holding him for 104 days until a judge found the state's foreign policy threat claims overly vague. Though facing a final removal order, Khalil remains protected from re-arrest while federal courts evaluate his First Amendment claims. He has also petitioned the Supreme Court to ensure judges retain authority to halt speech-based deportations.

Key points

  • Government agencies are being pressed to reveal whether federal officials or outside grou…: Government agencies are being pressed to reveal whether federal officials or outside groups influenced immigration courts to punish protected speech.
  • Pending federal litigation prevents immigration authorities from taking Khalil back into…: Pending federal litigation prevents immigration authorities from taking Khalil back into custody despite an active deportation order.
  • The legal fight could establish crucial speech and due process precedents for other targe…: The legal fight could establish crucial speech and due process precedents for other targeted non-citizen scholars like Badar Khan Suri.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

Former Columbia University graduate student Mahmoud Khalil sued the US Department of Justice (DOJ) on Wednesday for its failure to disclose documents showing what correspondence government officials may have had with the immigration judge and the appeal panel in his case.

This follows the administration’s failure to comply with a Freedom of Information Act request Khalil submitted in May, on the heels of a New York Times investigation that revealed his case was expedited and resulted in the recusal of members of the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA).

In April, the BIA issued what it called a "final order of removal" for Khalil, meaning he could be deported from the US. However, he is not permitted to be re-arrested while his free speech case in federal court continues to play out.

The judges who make up the BIA do not operate as an independent judiciary. The BIA falls under the control of the executive branch of government - in this case, the Trump administration. The same applies to all immigration courts, which operate under the purview of the DOJ.

New…

Politics