Politics1 min read

Labor won’t scrap ABC and SBC ombudsmen in favour of external body as suggested by antisemitism envoy

By · Via The Guardian · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The Albanese government will maintain existing internal watchdog structures at public broadcasters despite calls from Australia's antisemitism envoy to replace them. Community organizations remain divided, with some Jewish leaders demanding stronger accountability while other groups warn that such measures endanger free speech. Data from ABC Alumni Limited shows the internal ombudsman upheld only four Middle East bias complaints out of thousands received since October 2023. Ministers are currently awaiting the final findings of the Royal Commission into Antisemitism and Social Cohesion before evaluating wider policy responses.

Key points

  • The federal government will rely on existing media regulators rather than introducing ded…: The federal government will rely on existing media regulators rather than introducing dedicated external ombudsmen for public broadcasters.
  • Diverse community organizations disagree sharply on whether external media monitoring pro…: Diverse community organizations disagree sharply on whether external media monitoring protects social cohesion or undermines free speech.
  • Policy adjustments regarding antisemitism and media standards may be considered after Vir…: Policy adjustments regarding antisemitism and media standards may be considered after Virginia Bell delivers her royal commission report.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

The Albanese government won’t follow a suggestion by the antisemitism envoy to scrap the ABC and SBS ombudsmen and replace them with an external oversight body.

In a list of updated priorities released last month, Segal proposed an “external independent ombudsman” to monitor ABC and SBS coverage of the war in Gaza and to ensure publicly funded broadcasters were “held accountable to their own stated standards of accuracy and impartiality”.

“Many in the Jewish community remain concerned that coverage they perceive as one-directional may contribute to a negative – and even hostile – view by audiences of those who support Israel, or have sympathy for it,” Segal said in her updated plan to combat antisemitism.

Segal said the government should consider “transferring” responsibilities from the ABC and SBS ombudsmen to an “external independent ombudsman consistent with other sectors such as telecommunications and banking”.

The ABC said at the time its complaints process was “the most robust and transparent in the Australian media” and both broadcasters stated they were subject to external review by the Australian Communications and Media Authority (Acma).

Politics