Politics1 min read

Kemi and Andy put another nail in the coffin of his consensus politics | John Crace

By · Via The Guardian Politics · Published by Everything Blog

In short

Recent clashes at Prime Minister’s Questions highlighted the growing division between the two leaders over welfare policy and support for young people not in education, employment, or training. When questioned about the timeline for reducing the welfare bill, Andy Burnham defended redirecting spending toward back-to-work support while Kemi Badenoch dismissed his approach as focusing on vibes rather than actual cuts. The session ultimately deteriorated into further disagreements regarding the Milburn review and migration figures tied to a European Union agreement.

Key points

  • Hopes for a consensual political approach have collapsed into routine partisan friction b…: Hopes for a consensual political approach have collapsed into routine partisan friction between the two main party leaders.
  • Parliamentary questioning sessions are increasingly being treated as performative spectac…: Parliamentary questioning sessions are increasingly being treated as performative spectacles intended primarily to satisfy backbench politicians.
  • Andy Burnham has managed to avoid major political damage despite persistent and aggressiv…: Andy Burnham has managed to avoid major political damage despite persistent and aggressive clashes with Kemi Badenoch.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

Well, that didn’t take long. When Andy Burnham first arrived in No 10, he said he was determined to do things differently. He wanted a new, consensual politics where he would work with other parties to put the country back together. Safe to say, that dream is already dead in the water. At least when it comes to his exchanges with Kemi Badenoch at prime minister’s questions.

Andy might go through the motions of promising Ed Davey and various backbenchers a veneer of cross-party support that may or may not become reality – even Andy doesn’t have a clue which is which – but when it comes to Kemi, it’s now just a bloodless slanging match. Bloodless because there’s nothing really at stake. It’s all just a performance. Kemi has yet to land a blow on Burnham, so both leaders are merely playing to a gallery of their own backbenchers.

In fairness, it’s probably easiest this way. Even if Andy were to say: “You know what, Kemi? I think you’re right. Let’s try doing it your way,” Kemi would still…

Politics