Finance1 min read

ITAT deletes Rs 29 crore tax addition against US citizen working in India

By · Via Times of India · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The dispute originated when an assessing officer flagged a jump in Agarwal's foreign peak balances from Rs 10.82 crore to Rs 40.70 crore during the 2017-18 assessment year. The officer invoked Section 69A of the Income Tax Act alongside foreign interest adjustments, pushing the total assessed income to Rs 38.59 crore. The Delhi bench upheld the appellate authority's findings that the funds comprised salary, transfers, and interest covered under the India-US tax treaty. Consequently, the tribunal fully affirmed the deletion of the tax department's Rs 29.87 crore addition and Rs 5.36 lakh interest levy.

Key points

  • Comparing peak account balances across different years cannot legally substitute for an e…: Comparing peak account balances across different years cannot legally substitute for an examination of actual deposits and withdrawals.
  • Tax treaty provisions between India and the United States protected the taxpayer's foreig…: Tax treaty provisions between India and the United States protected the taxpayer's foreign bank account interest from the disputed domestic levy.
  • Procedural challenges against taxpayer evidence fail when the assessing officer already s…: Procedural challenges against taxpayer evidence fail when the assessing officer already scrutinized the records during earlier remand proceedings.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

NEW DELHI: The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Delhi, has dismissed the tax department’s appeal against the deletion of a Rs 29.87 crore addition made to the income of a US citizen over an increase in the peak balances of his foreign bank accounts.

In an order dated November 18, 2026, the tribunal held that the increase in account balances alone could not be treated as unexplained income. It also upheld the deletion of a separate Rs 5.36 lakh addition on interest earned from these accounts.

Case background

The case concerns Deepak Lal Agarwal, a US citizen working in India with Cairn India Limited. He filed his income tax return for the assessment year 2017-18, declaring an income of Rs 8.67 crore.

During scrutiny, the assessing officer noticed that the combined highest balances in his foreign bank accounts had increased from Rs 10.82 crore in 2015-16 to Rs 40.70 crore in 2016-17. The officer treated the difference of Rs 29.87 crore as unexplained money. He also found that Agarwal had earned Rs 5.36 lakh as interest from these accounts.

The…

Finance