Other1 min read

Indiana woman who owned home since 1989 loses fight over 1-foot fence shift

By · Via Times of India · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The Indiana Court of Appeals affirmed a lower court decision dismissing Deanne Ellen Gloppen's attempt to claim a grassy boundary strip between adjacent residential lots. Gloppen filed suit in October 2022 after neighbors Daniel and Julia Goldfarb installed a new fence roughly one foot south of an older barrier. The appellate judges determined that Gloppen failed to prove she maintained the strip or reasonably believed she had paid taxes on it. Her attorney acknowledged during summary judgment that each party only paid taxes on the real estate defined by their respective deeds.

Key points

  • Claimants must provide clear and convincing proof that they believed they were paying tax…: Claimants must provide clear and convincing proof that they believed they were paying taxes on the disputed boundary land.
  • Failing to maintain the contested parcel or make noticeable improvements weakens a homeow…: Failing to maintain the contested parcel or make noticeable improvements weakens a homeowner's claim of adverse possession.
  • Property taxes paid solely on deeded acreage cannot satisfy Indiana's adverse possession…: Property taxes paid solely on deeded acreage cannot satisfy Indiana's adverse possession tax requirement during boundary disputes.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

A fence moved by about a foot became the centre of a property dispute between neighbours in Indiana, where a homeowner claimed ownership of a grassy strip separating their properties. The woman, who had owned her house since 1989, argued that the land belonged to her despite the neighbouring owners' decision to install a replacement fence in 2022. However, the Indiana Court of Appeals ruled against her, finding that she had not established the legal requirements to claim the disputed property.

In its November 13, 2026, memorandum

decision in Deanne Ellen Gloppen v. Daniel Goldfarb, available on Justia, the appeals court affirmed a lower court ruling in favour of the neighbouring property owners. The judges examined whether Gloppen could establish ownership through adverse possession, a legal principle that can allow someone to acquire another person's land after meeting specific conditions over a required period. The court concluded that her evidence did not satisfy those conditions, particularly the requirement concerning property taxes.

Dispute began after neighbours moved the fence

Gloppen has owned and lived at her home at 304 Elmhurst Street…

Other