Other1 min read

Indiana mother denied custody change, father's health records; must pay $18,500

By · Via Times of India · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The Indiana Court of Appeals affirmed a Hamilton Superior Court decision that denied Sember Darland-Chappell sole legal custody of her three children and blocked her from reviewing Andrew Hahn's mental-health records. Although the parents divorced in February 2020 with shared legal custody, Hahn secured sole custody in May 2023 following an evaluation by clinical psychologist Dr. Bart Ferraro. The ruling preserves an alternating-week schedule while upholding an order requiring Darland-Chappell to pay $18,500 of Hahn's trial attorney fees. The case has now been remanded to the trial court to assess additional appellate legal fees she must pay to Hahn.

Key points

  • Protecting the therapeutic process between a parent and family therapist took precedence…: Protecting the therapeutic process between a parent and family therapist took precedence over custody record subpoenas.
  • The Indiana Court of Appeals fully upheld the Hamilton Superior Court's custody and evide…: The Indiana Court of Appeals fully upheld the Hamilton Superior Court's custody and evidentiary rulings.
  • The trial court must determine an additional fee amount that Darland-Chappell must pay fo…: The trial court must determine an additional fee amount that Darland-Chappell must pay for Hahn's appellate representation.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

An Indiana mother who tried to regain sole legal custody of her three children from her former husband and gain access to his mental-health records has lost her appeal. She must also pay more of his legal costs. In a ruling issued on 16 November 2026, the Indiana Court of Appeals rejected all the challenges brought by Sember Darland-Chappell against her former husband, Andrew Hahn. A three-judge panel upheld a Hamilton Superior Court order that denied her request to change custody, refused to let her see Hahn's therapy notes and ordered her to pay $18,500 towards his trial lawyer's fees. The appeals court also approved Hahn's request for appellate legal fees and sent the case back to the trial court to decide how much more she must pay. Judge Cale Bradford wrote the decision. Judges Patricia Riley Bailey and Elaine Brown Altice agreed with the ruling.

Seven years of court battles

Darland-Chappell and Hahn divorced on 19 February 2020, according to the Indiana Court of Appeals decision. Under their original divorce order, the former couple shared legal custody of their…

Other