Artificial Intelligence1 min read

I’m a priest. Silicon Valley’s search for the ‘soul’ of AI is deeply troubling | Rev Kevin Deal

By · Via The Guardian Business · Published by Everything Blog

In short

Tech developers in San Francisco are actively debating spiritual concepts with theologians, with Anthropic researchers even investigating whether chatbots could be trained to confess their wrongdoings. Local priest Rev Kevin Deal argues that software built for commercial productivity cannot possess a soul or replicate the divine spark of humanity. Deal points out the irony of executives trying to grant personhood to machines while reducing human workers to mere instruments of economic output. He urges industry founders to examine their own ethics through personal spiritual practices rather than searching for algorithmic consciousness.

Key points

  • Religious traditions view the human soul as fundamentally irreducible to programmed outpu…: Religious traditions view the human soul as fundamentally irreducible to programmed outputs.
  • Tech leaders risk dehumanizing workers while simultaneously trying to anthropomorphize co…: Tech leaders risk dehumanizing workers while simultaneously trying to anthropomorphize commercial tools.
  • Developers are urged to confront the ethical consequences of their software through perso…: Developers are urged to confront the ethical consequences of their software through personal reflection.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

Last month, religious leaders from across San Francisco gathered behind closed doors to discuss what it means to be human in the age of artificial intelligence.

Anthropic, the AI company operating only a couple of miles from my parish, has been courting priests, rabbis and theologians. Its billionaire cofounder, Christopher Olah, has even pressed Vatican advisers to take seriously the possibility that his company’s chatbot might possess consciousness.

As a priest, I find this pursuit deeply troubling. I welcome serious conversations about AI’s moral implications, especially theological ones. But the extraordinary effort to establish whether a machine might have consciousness, or possess a soul, reveals a profound misunderstanding of what makes us human.

Our souls and minds and bodies are so much more than the tasks we perform.

We as humans make mistakes, sometimes catastrophic ones, and then we may or may not try to correct course. We may double down in stubbornness, insisting on our rightness. We express ourselves, connect with others, reproduce, indulge, purge; we strive toward a goal, transform in an encounter, make vows, renege them, encounter…

Artificial Intelligence