Health1 min read

Illinois couple's $7.5m award over baby's death in childbirth upheld on appeal

By · Via Times of India · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The underlying medical malpractice lawsuit arose after Jeryis and Carlos Flores lost their newborn daughter, Cianie, following complications during childbirth. Plaintiffs presented testimony that medical staff should not have advised the mother to labor down, delayed a vital emergency cesarean section, and failed to apply a fetal scalp electrode in time. Defense arguments attributed the fatality to unpreventable blood flow problems, but jurors ultimately found the medical team negligent. The appellate court affirmed that the trial judge correctly instructed the jury on unanimity requirements, maintaining the multi-million dollar recovery.

Key points

  • Jurors in Illinois medical malpractice cases are not legally required to agree on the spe…: Jurors in Illinois medical malpractice cases are not legally required to agree on the specific negligent act committed by a defendant.
  • The appellate decision confirms Advocate Illinois Masonic Medical Center remains fully li…: The appellate decision confirms Advocate Illinois Masonic Medical Center remains fully liable for the multi-million dollar judgment.
  • Healthcare providers cannot invalidate a wrongful-death verdict simply because jurors rel…: Healthcare providers cannot invalidate a wrongful-death verdict simply because jurors relied on differing clinical errors to establish overall negligence.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

An Illinois appeals court has affirmed a $7.5 million wrongful-death verdict in favour of Jeryis and Carlos Flores, whose daughter Cianie died during childbirth at Advocate Illinois Masonic Medical Center in 2018. The November 13 decision by the Illinois Appellate Court, First District, rejected the hospital and medical staff’s argument that the jury’s verdict was invalid because jurors did not have to agree on the same specific act of negligence, according to the Justia U.S. Law case record.

The case involved claims that obstetrician Dr. Silvia Bicalho and nurse Josephine Jimenez failed to monitor the baby and intervene in time during labor. The appellate court found that the jury only needed to agree unanimously that each defendant was negligent and that the negligence caused the injury, not that all jurors agreed on which particular act or omission constituted that negligence. Read more details about this case, as per the record, here:

What happened in 2018

Jeryis Flores arrived at Advocate Illinois Masonic Medical Center at around 5 a.m. on September 26, 2018, in labor with her daughter, Cianie. Nurse Jimenez…

Health