Politics1 min read

Hoping for Britain to rejoin the EU with Andy Burnham? You may be waiting a long time | Timothy Garton Ash

By · Via The Guardian Politics · Published by Everything Blog

In short

According to Timothy Garton Ash's briefing, British Prime Minister Andy Burnham delivered his first major European policy speech, explicitly ruling out a return to freedom of movement during the current parliament. While labeling the existing hard Brexit inadequate, Burnham anchored his approach to the economic needs of Leave-voting areas like his own Makerfield constituency. Modest agreements, such as linked carbon emissions markets and youth mobility initiatives, are scheduled for an upcoming UK-EU summit. Substantive evaluations regarding deeper European integration have been postponed, with Burnham historically suggesting full re-entry might only occur within his lifetime.

Key points

  • Timothy Garton Ash indicates that any major structural shift in the UK's relationship wit…: Timothy Garton Ash indicates that any major structural shift in the UK's relationship with the European Union will not be explored until at least 2029.
  • Domestic political realities and concerns over losing historical opt-outs like the euro p…: Domestic political realities and concerns over losing historical opt-outs like the euro prevent the government from pursuing full EU membership.
  • The UK's European strategy remains focused on narrow economic resets rather than a return…: The UK's European strategy remains focused on narrow economic resets rather than a return to comprehensive continental integration or joint security structures.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

Ever since Andy Burnham became the British prime minister this summer, people all over Europe have been asking me one question: “Will the UK rejoin the EU?” Sometimes they add: “And if so, when?” None of the intermediate options between the current hard Brexit and Brejoin are of any interest at all to most other Europeans.

Measured against these great expectations, Burnham’s first big speech on Britain and Europe, delivered on Monday evening amid all the pomp and circumstance the City of London could furnish, must be considered a disappointment. It was both a cautious and a curiously old-fashioned speech.

Cautious in diagnosis: his bold statement that “we have lost more than we have gained in the last 10 years” was immediately followed by “the hard Brexit we were given is not good enough for Britain”. (So a soft Brexit would be fine?) Cautious in prescription: beyond the welcome modest steps to be agreed at this Friday’s UK-EU summit (easier access for food and agricultural products, linking our carbon emissions markets, creating a youth mobility scheme), anything this government does…

Politics