Business1 min read

Ford, Honda, Stellantis, VW sue New Jersey to block 'extortionate' vehicle repair law

By · Published by Everything Blog

In short

A coalition of major automakers filed a federal lawsuit against New Jersey state officials and the New Jersey Coalition of Automotive Retailers over the newly enacted recall and warranty compensation statute. The companies claim the law allows franchised dealers to mark up parts received at discounts and use labor multipliers to bill for unworked hours. Since taking effect on April 1, the measure has already generated dozens of invoices that exceed standard retail rates. The plaintiffs assert the state policy violates both the U.S. and state constitutions while clashing with federal recall oversight.

Key points

  • The lawsuit claims state mandates unlawfully prevent manufacturers from contesting inflat…: The lawsuit claims state mandates unlawfully prevent manufacturers from contesting inflated repair invoices or providing less expensive replacement parts.
  • Automakers contend the statute breaches the Commerce and Takings Clauses of the federal C…: Automakers contend the statute breaches the Commerce and Takings Clauses of the federal Constitution while conflicting with national recall regulations.
  • The litigation names both the state of New Jersey and the New Jersey Coalition of Automot…: The litigation names both the state of New Jersey and the New Jersey Coalition of Automotive Retailers as defendants in federal court.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

Nov 20 : Ford, Honda, Stellantis' FCA unit and Volkswagen sued New Jersey on Friday to block a new state law they say increases the amounts automakers must pay franchised dealers for warranty and recall repairs.

In a complaint filed in federal court in Trenton, New Jersey, the automakers said the New Jersey Motor Vehicle Open Recall Notice and Fair Compensation Act gives dealers a "blank check" to set prices for warranty, recall and other repair services, while prohibiting manufacturers from avoiding "extortionate" results or recovering the costs.

New Jersey's law will shift more than $375 million a year to dealers from automakers, giving dealers a "windfall" by imposing no obligation to use the money to improve customer service or boost compensation for employees, the automakers said.

"In short, the act rewards dealers for charging their customers more," the automakers said.

The office of New Jersey Attorney General Jennifer Davenport, who enforces the state's laws, did not immediately respond to requests for comment.

New Jersey's law took effect on April 1, after former Governor Phil Murphy signed it in September…

Business