Other1 min read

Flat maintenance hiked from ₹7,867 to ₹27,166

By · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The Maharashtra State Co-Operative Appellate Court granted interim relief to flat owners Mr Jayaswal and Mrs Nalawade in a Goregaon (West) housing society. Following a redevelopment project that expanded the complex from 40 to 215 members, the society raised the duo's monthly dues up to ₹29,266 based on wing-specific upkeep costs. In response to their payment refusal, the society withdrew the residents' security and housekeeping services in July 2022. The court halted the collection after discovering the society failed to execute promised safeguards, such as hiring an independent Chartered Accountant.

Key points

  • The appellate court temporarily barred the housing society from collecting the steeply en…: The appellate court temporarily barred the housing society from collecting the steeply enhanced maintenance fees.
  • Management failed to produce 2018 AGM minutes demonstrating majority approval or show com…: Management failed to produce 2018 AGM minutes demonstrating majority approval or show compliance with promised CA calculations.
  • The court has granted interim relief without issuing a final verdict on the legality of w…: The court has granted interim relief without issuing a final verdict on the legality of wing-wise maintenance charges.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

A recent judgement of the Maharashtra State Co-Operative Appellate Court shows how two home owners were made to pay nearly four times their monthly maintenance even though the society had not clearly explained how it calculated the increase.

The case concerns a housing society in Goregaon (West). Mr Jayaswal owns a flat D-101 and Mrs. Nalawade owns flat D-201. The society has four wings (A,B,C,D). It originally had 40 members, but after an approved redevelopment plan, the number of members increased to 215. There is a parking tower between C and D wings.

According to the redevelopment plan, there were only two flats in D wing measuring 1300 sq.ft each. These flats belong to Mr Jayaswal and Mrs. Nalawade. The redevelopment was completed in 2016 and on May 20, 2018, the housing society asked the flat owners to start paying society maintenance charges.

From 2018 to 2022, Jayaswal and Nalawade each paid Rs 7,867 in monthly maintenance charges. However, from 2022 onwards, the society said that the monthly maintenance amount needs to be increased to Rs Rs 27,166 and Rs…

Other