Finance1 min read

Finmin seeks review of SC's Yes Bank AT-1 bond ruling

By · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The finance ministry's petition mirrors earlier filings by the central bank and the lender contesting the judgment that upheld a Bombay High Court decision. The court determined that the appointed administrator possessed no legal authority to write down the debt because the measure was omitted from the formal reconstruction scheme. Furthermore, the bench severely reprimanded the central bank for remaining a bystander as the institution's Common Equity Tier-1 ratio deteriorated to a critical 0.6 percent.

Key points

  • The finance ministry, the central bank, and Yes Bank have all formally requested a review…: The finance ministry, the central bank, and Yes Bank have all formally requested a review of the adverse judgment.
  • Regulators were reprimanded by the court for allowing the bank's Common Equity Tier-1 rat…: Regulators were reprimanded by the court for allowing the bank's Common Equity Tier-1 ratio to decline to 0.6 percent.
  • The court ruled that investors should not bear the financial brunt of administrative fail…: The court ruled that investors should not bear the financial brunt of administrative failures that lacked explicit statutory backing.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

Earlier this month, Yes Bank and the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) also filed review petitions, seeking reconsideration of the judgment. The Supreme Court had upheld the Bombay High Court's ruling that the administrator did not have the authority to write down bonds that were not covered under the reconstruction scheme.

A bench of Justices Dipankar Datta and Augustine George Masih had ruled that Yes Bank's administrator had no authority to write off the bonds in the absence of a specific provision in the reconstruction scheme.

"The triumvirate of the RBI, the administrator and YES Bank, in conducting the entire affair of dealing with the bonds worth more than ₹8,415 crore, to put it mildly, is questionable," the judgment said.

The Supreme Court said the RBI had remained a mere bystander, allowing Yes Bank's Common Equity Tier-1 ratio to fall to an exceptionally low 0.6% while the bank's business was being conducted clandestinely. The court noted that material irregularities in the bank's functioning had been detected much earlier and criminal proceedings had also been initiated against its personnel.

Making investors…

Finance