Other1 min read

Farmer cuts 2,000ft row of neighbour's trees; Canadian court awards over $213k

By · Via Times of India · Published by Everything Blog

In short

Timothy Mullen cleared a mature 60-foot-deep tree line and filled an adjacent ditch on Judith Ann Murphy's 40-acre farm, later claiming a brief phone discussion granted him permission to address water issues on his neighbouring plot. Justice Pamela Hebner dismissed the verbal agreement defence after finding the contact was merely a preliminary conversation rather than an explicit legal consent. The court awarded Murphy over $213,000 to remediate the damaged border, a calculation grounded in what a reasonable owner would invest to restore the area. The Court of Appeal for Ontario later affirmed the trespass judgment in full, rejecting Mullen's appeal and adding $20,000 in legal costs.

Key points

  • The Court of Appeal for Ontario upheld the trespass ruling and assessed an additional twe…: The Court of Appeal for Ontario upheld the trespass ruling and assessed an additional twenty thousand dollars in legal costs against the defendants.
  • Justice Pamela Hebner ruled that Timothy Mullen failed to satisfy the legal burden of pro…: Justice Pamela Hebner ruled that Timothy Mullen failed to satisfy the legal burden of proving he had permission to access and clear the property.
  • Restitution damages of over two hundred thirteen thousand dollars were set based on stand…: Restitution damages of over two hundred thirteen thousand dollars were set based on standard principles of reasonable restoration costs rather than nominal replanting fees.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

In August and September 2012, Timothy Mullen entered his neighbour’s 40-acre property in Tilbury, Ontario, cut down a mature tree line of approximately 2,000 feet and filled in the drainage ditch beside it. The trees had separated the two farms. The court later found he did not have permission from the owner, Judith Ann Murphy. In 2018, the Ontario Superior Court held the defendants liable for trespass, and in 2020 it ordered them to pay $213,471.27 in damages. The Court of Appeal for Ontario dismissed their appeal in December 2021 and awarded Mrs Murphy costs of $20,000, all inclusive.

How the removal of the 2,000-foot tree line affected the neighbouring farm

According to the 2020 reasons for judgment of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice, the Murphy property is 40 acres, and the Mullen property is 48 acres. A row of trees and a ditch ran along the west side of the Murphy property, between the two farms. The court described the tree line as "approximately 2,000 feet long", running from the south end of the property at Highway 46…

Other