Business1 min read

Family buys $1.41m cottage, finds ban on expansion; wins $1.3m from broker

By · Via Times of India · Published by Everything Blog

In short

Relying on real estate agent Melanie Gowen's claims that the 1,200-square-foot cottage could be doubled in size, the buyers closed on the Polpis Road property in 2020. They learned months later that permanent restrictions barred any expansion, prompting them to sell the house and purchase a $3.1 million replacement using retirement loans. A Norfolk Superior Court jury determined the broker was predominantly negligent, awarding over $1.28 million to offset the buyers' losses. Gowen and her agency deny liability and have filed an appeal arguing the buyers reviewed the deed restrictions before closing.

Key points

  • Real estate professionals can face severe financial liability when misrepresenting proper…: Real estate professionals can face severe financial liability when misrepresenting property expansion limits to prospective buyers.
  • Selling the contested property at a higher price did not fully mitigate the family's over…: Selling the contested property at a higher price did not fully mitigate the family's overall financial losses.
  • The brokerage is actively appealing the ruling on the grounds that the buyers examined th…: The brokerage is actively appealing the ruling on the grounds that the buyers examined the restrictive documents before purchase.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

Squeezing eight family members into a 1,200-square-foot cottage sounds like the setup for a cramped summer sitcom, yet for a Connecticut couple, that coastal squeeze turned into a five-year courtroom drama. Hoping to carve out a spacious retreat on one of America’s priciest islands, Dr. Mary Murray and attorney Jeffrey Ment bought a modest Nantucket house on the promise that they could double its footprint, only to discover too late that legal restrictions froze the home’s size permanently.

Promises of expansion on Polpis Road

According to Realtor, Murray, an obstetrician, and Ment, a lawyer, reside in Westport, Connecticut, and regularly vacationed on Nantucket with their six children. After previously relying on William Raveis Nantucket agent Melanie Gowen to secure island rentals, the couple worked with her in 2020 to purchase a two-bedroom cottage at 151 Polpis Road for $1.41 million, though Nantucket Current noted the sale price at $1.45 million. With Nantucket’s median listing price hovering near $6 million, the buyers viewed the property as a rare foothold in an ultracompetitive market, Realtor report added.

Because a two-bedroom layout could…

Business