Science1 min read

Even scientists can't agree on what science actually is

By · Published by Everything Blog

In short

A new study published in Royal Society Open Science reveals that scientists frequently diverge on whether their discipline is an objective pursuit of truth or an imaginative, judgment-driven endeavor. By contrast, the general public generally views science as a consistent mechanism for establishing concrete facts, placing far less value on uncertainty or personal creativity. Intriguingly, the perspectives of the surveyed public aligned much closer with physicists and biologists than with social scientists or psychologists. These contrasting definitions highlight ongoing communication challenges and raise critical questions as artificial intelligence tools take on research tasks.

Key points

  • Non-scientists hold far more uniform views about the definitive nature of scientific rese…: Non-scientists hold far more uniform views about the definitive nature of scientific research than practicing researchers do.
  • Public dissatisfaction often stems from expecting definitive facts from a discipline that…: Public dissatisfaction often stems from expecting definitive facts from a discipline that scientists themselves view as evolving and creative.
  • Conflicting ideas regarding the scientific method complicate ongoing efforts to deploy ar…: Conflicting ideas regarding the scientific method complicate ongoing efforts to deploy artificial intelligence systems for automated scientific discovery.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

- Date:

- November 21, 2026

- Source:

- Santa Fe Institute

- Summary:

- Scientists cannot agree on what science actually is, and a new study finds their views are surprisingly more divided than those of the general public. The findings could help explain public frustration with scientific uncertainty and raise questions about how artificial intelligence might reshape future discoveries.

- Share:

Scientists dedicate their careers to uncovering how the world works, yet they have surprisingly different opinions about what science actually means. New research reveals that scientists disagree about the nature and purpose of science even more than the general public does.

The study, published in Royal Society Open Science, examined 18 different descriptions of science and found that researchers rarely embraced any of them without reservations. Even when scientists generally supported a particular definition, many questioned some aspect of it.

"What was surprising to me was that there was quite a bit of disagreement between scientists, including scientists who are in the same subfield," says Marina Dubova, who led the research while working as a postdoctoral researcher…

Science