Technology1 min read

Don’t blame cyber-attacks for recent outages. The real villain is the US economy | Bruce Schneier

By · Via The Guardian Business · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The recent wave of system collapses impacting entities like the FAA, Microsoft, Apple, and an unnamed classified NSA network were coincidental breakdowns rather than coordinated cyber assaults. Modern business incentives treat operational redundancy and security safeguards as non-revenue-generating expenses ripe for elimination. This economic framework encourages organizations to operate perpetually at the brink of failure, resulting in grounded flights and frozen financial services for ordinary citizens. Schneier maintains that technical upgrades will only occur once lawmakers counter corporate lobbying with enforceable fines and robust regulatory oversight.

Key points

  • Technological breakdowns stem primarily from economic models that prioritize short-term c…: Technological breakdowns stem primarily from economic models that prioritize short-term corporate profits over system reliability.
  • Organizations routinely externalize the financial and logistical costs of severe network…: Organizations routinely externalize the financial and logistical costs of severe network failures onto the public.
  • Meaningful infrastructure resilience cannot be achieved without stringent regulatory over…: Meaningful infrastructure resilience cannot be achieved without stringent regulatory oversight, major antitrust action, and enforceable corporate fines.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

It’s been a bad week for our computerized infrastructure. We’ve seen outages at Microsoft, the FAA, a handful of banks, United Airlines, an unnamed classified NSA network, and Apple. People should be forgiven for suspecting a coordinated cyber-attack, a common cause, or at least a conspiracy. But there is none.

The incidents are unrelated. They’re not the result of any cyber-attack, coordinated or not. And, even more surprising, they don’t seem to be the result of AI. (We can’t say anything about the NSA; we’ll probably never know the details of that one.) It’s really just a series of unfortunate coincidences.

None of them should surprise, though. Our computerized infrastructure is both vulnerable and fragile.

Much of it is old and has been incrementally patched and upgraded over the decades. A surprising amount of it is maintained by hobbyists, without any recompense. There often aren’t good backup systems. And more and more of it is centralized, meaning that individual failures have cascading consequences across many different aspects of our lives and society.

A lot of our tech infrastructure just barely…

Technology