Politics1 min read

CJI averts 'potential religious row', pulls cases from SC judge

By · Via Times of India · Published by Everything Blog

In short

Chief Justice Surya Kant and four senior Supreme Court judges withdrew two cases from a bench headed by Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah for exceeding roster limits. The reassigned matters included an August 4 directive ordering all states and Union Territories to remove stray animals from public spaces. Another pulled matter involved an unauthorized two-story building in Tamil Nadu that the bench had broadened on March 25 into a nationwide review of municipal building bylaw violations. Following these reassignments, the Chief Justice intends to examine other benches to catch and reallocate any similarly overextended cases.

Key points

  • Supreme Court benches outside the assigned public interest litigation roster are not perm…: Supreme Court benches outside the assigned public interest litigation roster are not permitted to initiate broad, nationwide judicial drives.
  • Administrative reassignments were executed to preserve case-distribution discipline and p…: Administrative reassignments were executed to preserve case-distribution discipline and prevent a potential religious controversy surrounding animal protection laws.
  • The Chief Justice plans to conduct a court-wide review to identify and reallocate other c…: The Chief Justice plans to conduct a court-wide review to identify and reallocate other cases improperly turned into public interest litigations.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

New Delhi: CJI Surya Kant's decision to withdraw two cases from the bench headed by Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah, which had expanded individual incidents of lapses on the part of authorities into pan-India judicial drives against similar illegalities, averted a potential religious controversy.The bench's Aug 4 order directing all states and UTs to remove stray animals from public places created a controversy as it is known that the majority of strays comprise cows and calves. A UP resident filed an application before the bench apprehending that the order was "capable of being implemented in a manner that may result in cows and their progeny being rounded up, transported or disposed of without regard to the special constitutional protection they are entitled to".

'Wasn't permissible for that particular bench to create PIL jurisdiction'

The applicant said, "Cows have been worshipped and revered in Indian society since ancient times as 'gaumata', and religious sentiments of the public..., particularly the Hindu community, are gravely hurt whenever cows are slaughtered or otherwise ill-treated."He said a blanket order for the removal of strays by SC ran…

Politics