Other1 min read

Chicken crosses road. Private-hire driver brakes. Passenger sues over injury, but claim doesn’t fly

By · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The legal dispute originated from a Feb. 19, 2024, traffic incident along Holland Road when passenger Yvonne Chen Qianyun alleged her back pain was aggravated by severe braking. Private-hire driver Tan Teng Kiat applied his brakes abruptly after a leading vehicle stopped suddenly to avoid a darting chicken. Judge Ng ruled Tan's rapid response was entirely reasonable under sudden emergency conditions, as he managed to halt in time to prevent a crash. The court subsequently ordered Chen to pay $15,000 in legal costs along with additional disbursements and taxes.

Key points

  • Drivers are not considered legally negligent when executing emergency stops to successful…: Drivers are not considered legally negligent when executing emergency stops to successfully prevent a vehicular collision.
  • The court recognized that ordinary, careful drivers would naturally brake forcefully duri…: The court recognized that ordinary, careful drivers would naturally brake forcefully during split-second road emergencies.
  • Legal principles do not assign liability to motorists for every unfortunate injury that o…: Legal principles do not assign liability to motorists for every unfortunate injury that occurs to innocent passengers.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

Chicken crosses road. Private-hire driver brakes. Passenger sues over injury, but claim doesn’t fly

SINGAPORE – A chicken darted across Holland Road, a vehicle braked and a private-hire driver behind it did the same to avoid a collision.

But the passenger in his car was unhappy with the sudden stop. She sued the driver for negligence, and she and the driver even disagreed in court over the identity and behaviour of the bird: she called it a jungle fowl that was “on the road”, while the driver said it was a rooster that “flew across” the road.

Unruffled, the judge who heard and later dismissed the case referred to the bird simply as a chicken.

“This was a trial that arose because a chicken crossed the road,” District Judge Jonathan Ng Pang Ern wrote in his grounds of decision dated Nov 18.

The incident happened on Feb 19, 2024, when Yvonne Chen Qianyun was a passenger in a private-hire car driven by Tan Teng Kiat.

As the car travelled along Holland Road, a chicken cut into the path of the…

Other