Other1 min read

Caregiver received over $30m from businessman; court orders fresh trial on gifts

By · Via Times of India · Published by Everything Blog

In short

Between 2009 and 2019, a Canadian businessman executed at least 393 transactions moving over $30 million to his housebound wife's caregiver, funding real estate, jewellery, luxury travel, and cars. The Ontario Court of Appeal ordered a fresh trial after concluding the initial judge mistakenly placed the burden of proof on the estate rather than the recipient. Additionally, the trial judge erred by treating the couple's intimate relationship as legal corroboration and improperly excluding handwritten notes that indicated the funds were tracked as investments. The retrial will definitively settle ownership of the transferred wealth, though prior orders directing the return of the wife's funds…

Key points

  • The Ontario Court of Appeal ordered a new trial because the original judge incorrectly re…: The Ontario Court of Appeal ordered a new trial because the original judge incorrectly reversed the legal burden of proof under the law of resulting trusts.
  • An intimate personal relationship cannot serve as statutory independent corroboration und…: An intimate personal relationship cannot serve as statutory independent corroboration under the Evidence Act to prove that monetary transfers were gifts.
  • The caregiver remains legally obligated to repay $1,938,000 of the wife's money while the…: The caregiver remains legally obligated to repay $1,938,000 of the wife's money while the deceased's estate retains an 80 percent interest in a horse farm.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

A wealthy Canadian businessman transferred more than $30 million to the woman hired to care for his ill wife, and after his death the question of whether those transfers were gifts has become the centre of a major estate dispute. On November 12, the Ontario Court of Appeal ordered a new trial in Waters Estate v. Henry, finding that the original judge made errors in how he treated the evidence and the legal burden, according to Blaneys Appeals and Law360 Canada.

The case involves a man who hired a personal support worker for his housebound wife in 2009. Within weeks, he began transferring large sums to her, and over the next decade he moved more than $30 million across at least 393 transfers. The Court of Appeal has now sent the matter back for a fresh trial to determine whether the money was intended as a gift or was held in trust for the estate.

What the transfers involved

Between 2009 and December 2019, the businessman transferred more than $30 million to the caregiver in at least 393 transactions. About…

Other