Politics1 min read

‘Bland, faintly sugary and cardboardy’: the best (and worst) supermarket porridge oats, tasted and rated

By · Via The Guardian Money · Published by Everything Blog

In short

M&S Organic Traditional Oats led the comparative tasting after earning praise for its tender bite, velvety texture, and umami nuttiness, while family-milled Mornflake Mighty Oats secured the best value spot. Other high marks went to organic products from Tesco, Flahavan’s, and Glebe Farm, alongside premium jumbo oats from Co-op. Mainstream options lagged behind, with Quaker criticized for a claggy consistency and Aldi Everyday Essentials ranking at the very bottom due to its watery, cardboardy profile.

Key points

  • Organic oats consistently outperformed conventionally grown alternatives in delivering su…: Organic oats consistently outperformed conventionally grown alternatives in delivering superior overall flavor during the comparative evaluation.
  • The preparation style and final texture depend directly on whether oats are cut prior to…: The preparation style and final texture depend directly on whether oats are cut prior to rolling or kept whole as jumbo flakes.
  • Budget and mainstream options including Aldi Everyday Essentials and Quaker suffered from…: Budget and mainstream options including Aldi Everyday Essentials and Quaker suffered from texture flaws ranging from clagginess to watery liquid.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

In the winter of 2003-04, my girlfriend and I hosted a Scottish family at a chalet in Val d’Isère. Full of chef bravado, I promised the father that I’d make him the best bowl of breakfast porridge he’d ever had. He, of course, turned up his nose at my bowl of sweet dessert, which I’d laced with cream and sugar, and showed me how to make porridge with just water and salt instead. I’ve never looked back.

In my experience, most jumbo oats need twice as much water as the packet instructions suggest, as well as three times as long to cook and turn satisfyingly creamy. Regular and vigorous stirring is essential, too, as is the sea salt, which turns a bland bowl of pap into a naturally sweet, earthy and nutty porridge.

For this test, I cooked each brand according to the recipe on the packet, using a 40g portion for most of them, but with varying quantities of water and cooking times (of course, adjust these to taste). The products are a mixture of porridge oats, which are…

Politics