Business1 min read

Beauty advent calendars can cost hundreds - but are they value for money?

By · Published by Everything Blog

In short

Driven largely by shoppers aged 18 to 34, cosmetic countdown boxes have grown into a lucrative holiday market fueled by unboxing videos and artificial scarcity. However, heightened scrutiny over filler items and inflated product valuations is leading consumers to question whether the steep upfront prices translate to actual savings. As backlash over cheap inclusions grows, buyers are increasingly examining itemized lists and trading unwanted contents to justify the expense. Highlighting this frustration, Kim Kardashian’s brand, Skims, recently refunded its $148 calendar after customers heavily criticized inclusions like scrunchies and hair clips.

Key points

  • Critics argue these boxes lack genuine value because customers are exceptionally unlikely…: Critics argue these boxes lack genuine value because customers are exceptionally unlikely to use every included item.
  • Savvy consumers are attempting to protect their investments by reviewing item lists early…: Savvy consumers are attempting to protect their investments by reviewing item lists early and exchanging products in online trading groups.
  • Industry experts remain split on whether calendars offer authentic savings below retail p…: Industry experts remain split on whether calendars offer authentic savings below retail prices or merely push unwanted travel-sized fillers.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

- Published

It's easy to see the appeal of a beauty advent calendar. Like many women at this time of year, Julia says she often finds herself tempted to splurge on one - especially a perfume calendar. But she takes quite an unsentimental approach.

"I always look at what's in them. If I like enough of the fragrances, I'll buy it," says the 39-year old, who works as a senior commercial manager in engineering.

Luxury advent calendars are supposed to offer the thrill of a surprise but, for Julia, it is more important she actually wants the items inside - a thought that is also striking more and more customers in the wake of the scandal over the Skims calendar.

This week, Kim Kardashian's beauty brand offered all of its customers refunds for its $148 (£110) calendar after being widely criticised on social media over the quality of its contents, with some customers likening the hair clips, scrunchies and keychains inside to things you might find down the back of a sofa.

Julia says she earns a good salary but…

Business