Other1 min read

Arizona HOA loses bid to force arbitration over disabled son's golf cart gate

By · Via Times of India · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The conflict began in November 2024 when the couple formally asked to install a wider backyard double gate to accommodate their disabled son's golf cart. After the Wigwam Creek South Community Association denied the application and affirmed its rejection, the family initiated legal action against the board. The association attempted to divert the fight into private proceedings using its Declaration of Covenants, Conditions and Restrictions alongside community living guidelines. Both a trial judge and the state appellate court rejected that maneuver, preserving the dispute for public judicial review.

Key points

  • Homeowners associations cannot mandate private arbitration when their governing contractu…: Homeowners associations cannot mandate private arbitration when their governing contractual rules violate basic fairness standards.
  • The appellate decision allows the family to proceed with their case in court and recover…: The appellate decision allows the family to proceed with their case in court and recover reasonable appeal-related legal fees.
  • Neighborhood guidelines and covenants are subject to judicial oversight when residents ch…: Neighborhood guidelines and covenants are subject to judicial oversight when residents challenge the impartiality of board enforcement.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

An Arizona couple who wanted to replace a backyard gate so their disabled son could park his golf cart at home have won a legal fight against their homeowners' association (HOA). An appeals court turned down the association's effort to force the family into private arbitration, allowing their lawsuit to move forward in court. Kevin and Jennifer LoPresto had asked the Wigwam Creek South Community Association to let them swap their single gate for a wider double gate. They explained that the wider opening was needed so their disabled son could park his golf cart in the backyard. The association denied their request and later argued that the dispute had to be settled through private arbitration instead of a public court.

However, the Arizona Court of Appeals backed the lower court's refusal to order arbitration. In its September 25, 2026, memorandum decision, the court ruled that the arbitration rules used by the association were one-sided and could not be enforced against the couple. This ruling means the LoPrestos can keep fighting their case against the HOA in court. The appeals…

Other