Artificial Intelligence1 min read

AI-generated videos, photos alone don’t amount to forgery: HC

By · Via Times of India · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The case originated in Bilaspur district after police registered an FIR under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita over posts claiming a man improperly benefited relatives through a public scheme. Authorities seized mobile devices, initiated forensic evaluations, and attempted to charge the creators with forgery and inciting public fear. However, the court found no evidence that the synthetic media disrupted public order, induced offences against the state, or met the statutory criteria for document tampering.

Key points

  • Defamation constitutes a non-cognisable offence that mandates a formal complaint before a…: Defamation constitutes a non-cognisable offence that mandates a formal complaint before a competent magistrate rather than police intervention.
  • Fabricated digital imagery cannot be prosecuted as forgery without evidence of unauthoris…: Fabricated digital imagery cannot be prosecuted as forgery without evidence of unauthorised alterations, false attributions, or deceptive acquisition.
  • Circulating false material does not justify criminal charges unless it demonstrably threa…: Circulating false material does not justify criminal charges unless it demonstrably threatens public order or induces offences against the state.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

SHIMLA: Merely circulating AI-generated videos and photographs containing allegedly false and defamatory content does not amount to forgery under the law, and police cannot investigate a private defamation complaint by invoking cognisable offences that are not made out, Himachal Pradesh high court has ruled.

Quashing an FIR registered against two persons over

Facebook posts against a man and his family, the bench of Justice Rakesh Kainthla held that defamation is a non-cognisable offence and requires a complaint before the competent magistrate.

“The registration of an FIR for the commission of cognisable offences, which are not made out, as a subterfuge to investigate a non-cognisable offence that concerns a private dispute cannot be permitted. Permitting so would defeat the legislative intent that private offences should not be investigated by police,” the bench underlined.

Justice Kainthla observed that the FIR did not allege that the AI-generated videos or photographs were falsely projected as having been created by someone else, altered without lawful authority after their creation, or obtained through deception from a person unable to understand their contents.

Merely claiming that the…

Artificial Intelligence