Science1 min read

A 50-year-old theory about evolution may have been wrong all along

By · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The study, published in PLOS Biology, examined the largest collection of spontaneous mutations assembled to date in baker's yeast and Escherichia coli. Authors Dr. Sofia Radrizzani and Professor Laurence D. Hurst discovered that earlier research was likely misled by natural selection, which rapidly weeds out harmful mutations in critical genes before scientists can detect them. This rapid elimination previously created a false impression that essential genes experienced fewer mutations overall. Furthermore, because mutations are already uncommon, organisms derive little evolutionary benefit from expending energy to shield specific vital regions.

Key points

  • Evolutionary evidence indicates that genetic mutations arise completely at random rather…: Evolutionary evidence indicates that genetic mutations arise completely at random rather than being targeted or suppressed based on gene importance.
  • Natural selection struggle to favor specialized protective mechanisms because mutations i…: Natural selection struggle to favor specialized protective mechanisms because mutations in individual genes are already relatively rare events.
  • Earlier studies supporting targeted mutation suppression were misled by failing to accoun…: Earlier studies supporting targeted mutation suppression were misled by failing to account for the swift removal of lethal variations from populations.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

- Date:

- November 21, 2026

- Source:

- University of Bath

- Summary:

- A decades-old theory suggesting that evolution protects its most important genes from mutations has been dealt a major blow. An extensive new analysis of mutations in bacteria and yeast found no evidence that essential genes mutate less frequently than other genes. Researchers say earlier studies may have been misled by harmful mutations that disappeared through natural selection before scientists could detect them.

- Share:

For more than 50 years, scientists have debated a provocative idea about evolution: Could organisms protect their most important genes by making them less likely to mutate? First proposed in 1972, the hypothesis challenges the traditional understanding of how genetic changes arise. Now, new research from the University of Bath suggests that the evidence supporting this idea has been misleading.

In a study published in PLOS Biology, Dr. Sofia Radrizzani and Professor Laurence D Hurst of the University of Bath's Centre for Evolution examined the largest collection of spontaneous genetic mutations assembled to date. Their analysis focused on two microorganisms: the…

Science