Other1 min read

95-year-old widow loses appeal in 10-year garden row, faces £1m legal bill

By · Via Times of India · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The decade-long clash began in 2015 when the Morgans put up a fence on a 45-square-metre piece of land in Sissinghurst, Kent, sparking mutual accusations of trespass and damage. A 2021 trial awarded Egan £2,600 for trespass and an extra £3,250 in lieu of an injunction, but the court established the disputed fence as the legitimate boundary. In 2024, the trial judge formally designated the mixed results a "score draw," refusing to award legal costs to either side. Egan challenged that decision by citing Neil Morgan's offensive behavior toward legal figures, but the High Court ruled the conduct did not justify altering the original costs determination.

Key points

  • Mary Egan remains responsible for legal expenses exceeding £1 million following the dismi…: Mary Egan remains responsible for legal expenses exceeding £1 million following the dismissed appeal.
  • The trial judge determined the litigation outcome was a "score draw" because the fence re…: The trial judge determined the litigation outcome was a "score draw" because the fence remained intact.
  • Conduct that unnecessarily increases litigation fees does not automatically overturn a ju…: Conduct that unnecessarily increases litigation fees does not automatically overturn a judicial decision to split costs.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

A 95-year-old widow has been left facing a legal bill exceeding £1 million after the High Court rejected her latest attempt to recover the costs of a decade-long dispute with her neighbours over a small strip of garden land in Kent, UK.

Mary Egan challenged an earlier ruling that required both sides to pay their own legal expenses, arguing that she had largely won the original case and should not be held responsible for the enormous costs. However, Mr Justice Tappin dismissed her appeal, leaving the previous costs order unchanged.

The dispute involved businessman Neil Morgan, 65, and his wife Fiona, 61, who live next door to Egan in Sissinghurst, near Tunbridge Wells. The disagreement centred on approximately 45 square metres of grass, trees and scrub along a boundary measuring around 60 metres, according to The Independent.

Despite the limited size of the disputed area, the neighbours spent years in court, with Egan claiming to have accumulated more than £1 million in legal fees.

How a garden fence triggered a decade-long legal battle

The disagreement began in 2015 when the…

Other