Other1 min read

95-year-old widow loses appeal in 10-year fence row, faces over £1m in costs

By · Via Times of India · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The dispute concluded with Recorder John Dagnall deeming the case an effective "score draw" after allowing the fence to stand as the new property border. Because neighbours Neil and Fiona Morgan largely represented themselves while Mrs Kinnear hired legal counsel, she was left to bear an enormous financial burden under an order requiring both parties to cover their own expenses. She appealed that costs ruling by pointing to abusive communications sent by Neil Morgan toward court personnel and judges. High Court judge Mr Justice Tappin criticized the deplorable conduct but upheld the original decision, leaving Mrs Kinnear liable for her own fees.

Key points

  • Mrs Kinnear remains responsible for over £1 million in legal bills because she retained c…: Mrs Kinnear remains responsible for over £1 million in legal bills because she retained counsel while her opponents largely self-represented.
  • The courts deemed the outcome a score draw and ordered each side to cover their respectiv…: The courts deemed the outcome a score draw and ordered each side to cover their respective legal costs.
  • The judiciary determined that the extensive money and court time spent on the decade-long…: The judiciary determined that the extensive money and court time spent on the decade-long row was wholly disproportionate.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

A 95-year-old British widow is facing legal bills of more than £1 million after spending a decade fighting her neighbours over a garden fence. The High Court has rejected an appeal by Margaret Kinnear against a ruling that she must pay her own legal costs in the dispute. This is despite her having successfully won a trespass claim against the couple living next door. The dispute involved a boundary line in the wealthy village of Sissinghurst, near Tunbridge Wells in Kent. At the centre of the case was a narrow strip of land measuring around 45 square metres. A judge described the area as being of "extremely limited, if any, usable or other value."

A costly decade-long legal feud

Neighbours Neil and Fiona Morgan put up a new fence in late 2015, replacing an existing fence along the boundary of Mrs Kinnear's property. According to court reports, the Morgans first placed fence posts on Mrs Kinnear's land without asking her. They later removed the posts and put up a second fence. This was followed by a temporary fence that extended…

Other